Let’s start with the basics: Conventional vs. organic vs. regenerative

I had a blog post written and ready to go. I was working on the visuals to go with the post when something happened. My husband had a friend over for a glass of wine. 

My husband is an extrovert. I am a homebody. He pulls me outside my comfort zone and I am grateful 99% of the time…after the fact. It’s a good thing he’s got tenacity.

ANYWAY! He texted me to come in and say hi to our friend, so I did. I asked him about what he’s been up to and asked how his wife is doing. He’s such a nice guy. I was happy to see him. See? 99%.

My husband, who’s excited about what I’m doing and is just as curious about where this will take me as I am, tells our friend about my journey into regenerative agriculture. We chat. 

Our friend asks great questions. 

Then he pauses and says, “This is what I really want to know. When I go into Whole Foods and there are strawberries, some are organic and some are not. What’s the difference?”

The What

Today I’m going to start with the basics, and we will use sweet, delicious strawberries as our example. I am going to give you a simple comparison of a conventional strawberry, an organic strawberry, and a regenerative strawberry. 

The Why

This is the basis of everything I’m trying to learn and share. If we can identify healthier food choices, we become healthier. 

If we know what’s missing, we know what to ask for.

Just the facts, ma’am

The table below shows a very rudimentary comparison of how strawberries can be grown. All 3 images look the same because you can’t tell how something is grown just by looking at it. But what’s on and inside it can be very different, for sure.

Conventional farms can use chemicals to grow the fruit and then coat the fruit with a chemical called an ethylene-action inhibitor to slow the ripening of the fruit so it can travel longer from farm to store without going rotten. Conventional strawberries are also grown in a way that kills soil life, life that would produce food richer in nutrients.

Organic farms that are certified organic (see the next image for the label) must resort to more natural methods to fertilize and ward off weeds and pests. They do not use any chemicals for growing or to slow ripening. Other methods can be used to do that.  They also farm in a way that does help the soil life to an extent, so the fruit produced there tends to have more nutrients than conventional fruits. In summary – no chemicals, and more nutrients.

Regenerative farms, there are only 3 in the world that are officially certified for strawberries (yes only 3), go to the next level. They are like Organic plus. They implement practices that regenerate life in the soil. The strawberries from these farms are chemical free and they cultivate even more nutrients per berry.  Amazing! We want more of these!

If you think you’ve read enough, jump on down to What you can do. But if you’re still curious…

Let’s go down the rabbit hole, shall we?

THE SOIL

Everything starts with how farmers treat their soil. Most of Earth’s soils are depleted. Depleted soils are soils devoid of a rich ecosystem of life – the life that unlocks nutrients for plants. Nutrients = minerals + vitamins + phytonutrients. Soil naturally has minerals present but in a form that is locked away from plants. By using farming methods that encourage soil life (fungi, bacteria, and more), the farmers unlock minerals and add organic matter that can feed plants the nutrients they need, in a form that is digestible. Some of those farming methods are listed in the table above – cover crops, rotation and less tillage or plowing. These methods lead to healthier soils, which in turn, lead to healthier food.

CONVENTIONAL FARMING

Conventional farming is like putting lipstick on a pig. It has, over time, depleted soil on a grand scale. The soil is devoid of bio-available nutrients? Dump on chemical nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium to grow a crop. The soil can’t hold water? Use a LOT of water, all the time to make sure the plant gets some before it dries up or gets carried away. The crops are getting weedy and have pests and diseases? Dump on chemical pesticides and herbicides. Results – a lot of plants that are mere shells of what they could be. This produces quantity, sure, but not quality.  

ORGANIC FARMING

Organic farming pays a lot more attention to the soil. They don’t dump on chemicals, which is huge because many of the chemicals kill the life in the soil. They rotate the crops as different types of plants invite life that makes all sorts of nutrients bio-available in the soil. One result is less fertilizing is needed. For example, legumes, like soybeans and chickpeas, make soils richer in nitrogen because when you plant them, a certain type of fungi that likes their sugars will make nitrogen, naturally occurring in the soil, bio-available for the plant and make an exchange. So the next crop rotated in will find more bio-available nitrogen in the soil.

REGENERATIVE FARMING

Regenerative farming is ALL about soil life. The healthiest of soils has more living organisms in one teaspoon than there are people on the planet. And it’s this soil that grows a more nutrient-dense and robust plant. It does so by taking minerals, like zinc, copper, and magnesium, and making them available for the plant to digest. Without that life in the soil, the plants are not able to “eat” those minerals. And then WE don’t get to eat those minerals. That life also delivers phytochemicals to the plants. Those phytochemicals help the plants fight disease, and guess what – they help US fight disease by strengthening our immune systems.  

I hope this begins to explain some of the differences in the food available for purchase at most grocery stores. If more of us choose to buy organic, more will become available. Consumers like us can influence markets – what farms and food companies provide us. So let’s vote with our dollar as much as we can!

What you can do

  1. I’ll say this every time. Buy food with the certified organic alliance label whenever possible. If you can’t find it, buy food that is certified organic.
  2. Organic can get expensive. Know which conventional fruits and vegetables tend to have the most chemical residue on them, so you know how to be selective. I understand that working on a budget limits choice. Here are links to the Environmental Working Group’s Dirty Dozen and Clean 15. I won’t make you guess – at the top of the list of the Dirty Dozen – Strawberries.
  3. Sign a petition to encourage the government to pass a farm bill this fall that supports soil health. This will lead to healthier options at the grocery store.  https://regenerateamerica.com/petition/#/4/
  4. Ask me questions in the comments section! I’ve mentioned some terms you might want me to explain (like tillage). I hope this has answered more questions than created them, but I won’t know unless you ask!

11 responses to “Let’s start with the basics: Conventional vs. organic vs. regenerative”

  1. I’m curious where in the US can one buy regenerative strawberries and other fruits?

    • Hi Robyn! Right now, it is a growing but tiny niche. Below is a link to a website that shows you the brands of food products that have the label, as well as the farms around the world. Locally, though, which for us is Ann Arbor, MI, I personally haven’t seen fruits or vegetables yet that have the Regenerative Organic Alliance certification. If someone else has, please reply to this comment! https://regenorganic.org/roc-directory/

  2. Hi Melissa – love this post, but have a question about it. I was under the impression that organically grown food can have pesticides/fungicides/other chemicals applied as long as they are organic (derived from organic compounds, not all of which – like, say, arsenic – are safe). Is that correct?

    • Yes, thanks for clarifying, Shannon. The main goal for organic is to use ecosystem management rather than synthetic chemicals to control pests and stimulate growth. Inputs derived from organic compounds are more likely to be approved for organic farming. The USDA regulates the list of approved inputs for organic farms. Love the comment! Thanks!

  3. In the chart you included, it seems that the only difference between organic and regenerative is the potential for improved taste? Could you please share a chart in the future that further details the differences between organic and regenerative? At Whole Wallet, I believe you can pay about 20% more for regeneratively raised eggs, but why… ?

    • Hi Jeff. Thanks for commenting! To answer your questions:
      1. I should have indicated that based on studies I’ve read and read about, it’s likely regenerative practices result in even more nutrient density than organic. Although, I don’t want to pit organic against regenerative. Both do good things for our soil. Regenerative just takes it further and the results seem to be even better all around for humans and our planet. I will go over this more in future posts. Thanks for your patience.
      2. Price differentials – some are market-based, which means the price is reflective of the assumption of willingness to pay. But higher prices are also an indicator that – (1) government programs and incentives are largely geared towards conventional production agriculture (higher yields) versus higher quality organic/regenerative agriculture. What that means is that money to subsidize farmers that would allow them to lower prices are not yet (fingers crossed) available to organic and regenerative farms. (2) Most regenerative farms are not at a scale or part of a supply chain that allows for operational efficiencies that would allow them to run at a lower cost and therefore they may need to charge more to cover costs and still see a profit. Hopefully, that will change as regenerative practices grow, but for now, I hope you see the value in a better-quality product.

  4. Hi Melissa,

    I love this post. As a frequent purchaser of strawberries, raspberries and blueberries I am now going to look into more organic options. Is there any way to safely remove the checmical residue on the conventionally farmed fruits before eating them?
    Thanks!

    • Hi Michelle! Thanks so much! I did a bit of research before responding here. I see that people have tried all kinds of options to try to remove pesticide residue from produce, including washing berries in warm salt water or vinegar and water. But the Michigan State’s Center for Research on Ingredient Safety states, “While you can remove pesticide residues using a soaking solution such as vinegar and water or salt and water, it’s not advisable. There’s a small risk the chemical reaction between the pesticides and the solution could produce potentially harmful compounds.” It seems that the safest way is to rinse or soak them in warm water for about a minute. It will remove some of the residue, but not all. The National Pesticide Center at Oregon State University says that no method has proven to reduce pesticide residue by 100%. So organic, when available, is the better choice. The large grocery chains, such as Kroger, Meijer, Costco and Walmart have organic sections. Good luck and thanks for reading!

  5. What an awesome blog!! It’s comprehensive but not overwhelming, you provide links for more info, and the “What you can do” section is my favorite! And the personal anecdote intro! 😍

  6. This is really awesome and interesting info. I’ve known bits and pieces about the state of the soil on the planet but the practical suggestions you provide are super helpful!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Digestible

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading